Poetry 패키지가 섹션 제목 주위의 수직 공간을 이상한 방식으로 변경합니다.

Question

패키지 를 사용하면 poetry섹션 제목 주위에 일관된 공간을 확보하는 데 문제가 있습니다. 내 시는 모두 제목으로 시작합니다 \section. 때로는 두 개의 시가 같은 페이지에 설정되어 있습니다. 때로는 시가 한 페이지 이상을 넘을 때도 있습니다(현재 poem환경은 으로 일시 중지되고 그림이 포함된 PDF가 포함되며 시는 첫 번째 줄의 시작 부분에서 \\*으로 다시 시작됩니다 ). \*그러나 이로 인해 제목 앞의 공간이 변경됩니다. 즉, "오버플로 텍스트"와 제목과의 거리가 같은 페이지에서 시작하고 끝나는 시와 아래 섹션 제목 사이의 거리보다 작습니다.

일반 텍스트로는 이 문제가 발생하지 않습니다. 즉, 페이지가 일반 텍스트로 시작되고 새 섹션이 시작되면 섹션 제목 앞의 공백은 페이지가 새 섹션으로 시작된 것과 동일합니다.

우주~ 후에섹션 제목은 제목 뒤에 시가 오느냐 일반 텍스트가 오느냐에 따라 바뀌지만, 적어도 일관성은 있고 오버플로 여부에 따라 바뀌지 않습니다. 하지만 poem환경이 한 페이지에 포함될 때와 비교하여 두 페이지로 분할되면 다음 타이틀 앞에 작지만 눈에 띄는 공간을 차지하게 됩니다.

다양한 조합을 모두 보여주고 싶었기 때문에 MWE가 좀 깁니다. 섹션 2와 3 주변의 공간 차이가 주요 문제입니다. 다른 섹션은 대조를 위해 존재합니다. 참고하시기 바랍니다poetry 다른 패키지와 충돌하는 것처럼 보이므로 로컬에서 실행하면 컴파일되지 않을 수 있습니다. 여기에서 볼 수 있는 Overleaf 예:https://www.overleaf.com/read/qggmxspxsxms

MWE:

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{poetry}\poemlinenumsfalse
\setlength{\parindent}{0pt}

\begin{document}
\section{The very first, -/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\*

\newpage
\* Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{First, P/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{Following, P/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}


\newpage
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\section{First, T/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{Following, P/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\newpage
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\section{First, T/T}
Text Text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text


\section{Following, T/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text


\section{Following, T/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\newpage
\section{Top of page, T/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\*

\newpage

\* Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{First, P/T}
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\section{Following, T/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}


\section{Following, P/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is a poem

\end{document}

Answer 1

나는 당신의 간격 문제가 무엇인지 파악하지 못했습니다. 저는 poetry패키지를 사용해본 적이 없습니다. 이것이 도움이 될지 모르겠습니다. verse패키지 대신 패키지(내가 개발했다는 ​​경고)를 사용하도록 코드를 변경 하고 시 제목에 대신 poetry을 사용했습니다 .verse \poemtitle{...}\section{...}

% poemprob.tex  SE 640836

\documentclass{article}

\usepackage{verse}

%\usepackage{poetry}\poemlinenumsfalse
\setlength{\parindent}{0pt}

\begin{document}

\tableofcontents

\poemtitle{The very first, -/P}
\begin{verse}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\*

\newpage
\* Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{verse}

\poemtitle{First, P/P}
\begin{verse}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{verse}

\poemtitle{Following, P/P}
\begin{verse}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{verse}


\newpage
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\poemtitle{First, T/P}
\begin{verse}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{verse}

\poemtitle{Following, P/P}
\begin{verse}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{verse}

\newpage
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\section{First, T/T}
Text Text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text


\section{Following, T/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text


\section{Following, T/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\newpage
\poemtitle{Top of page, T/P}
\begin{verse}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\*

\newpage

\* Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{verse}

\section{First, P/T}
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\poemtitle{Following, T/P}
\begin{verse}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{verse}

\section{Following, P/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is a poem

\end{document}

%%%%%% ORIGINAL MWE FOLLOWS %%%%%%%%%%%%%%

\documentclass{article}

{poetry}\poemlinenumsfalse
\setlength{\parindent}{0pt}

\begin{document}
\section{The very first, -/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\*

\newpage
\* Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{First, P/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{Following, P/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}


\newpage
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\section{First, T/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{Following, P/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\newpage
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\section{First, T/T}
Text Text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text


\section{Following, T/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text


\section{Following, T/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\newpage
\section{Top of page, T/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\*

\newpage

\* Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}

\section{First, P/T}
Type-setting is a nightmare

This is plain text

\section{Following, T/P}
\begin{poem}
Poem poem, please behave\\
So my peace of mind you save\\
Type-setting is a nightmare\\
This is a poem\\-
\end{poem}


\section{Following, P/T}
Text text, please behave

So my peace of mind you save

Type-setting is a nightmare

This is a poem

\end{document}

Answer 2

문제를 이해하고 있는지 잘 모르겠습니다. 시의 기록에는 환경 전후의 공간을 관리하는 \poemtopskip과 \poembotskip이 있다.

    \documentclass{article}
    %https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/640836/poetry-package-changes-vertical-space-around-section-headings-in-strange-ways/640918#640918
    \usepackage{poetry}\poemlinenumsfalse
    \setlength{\parindent}{0pt}

    \usepackage{paracol}
    \usepackage[margin=2cm]{geometry}
    \begin{document}
    Default
    \begin{paracol}{2}
        \section{With the environment poem}
        \begin{poem}
            Poem poem, please behave\\
            So my peace of mind you save\\
            Type-setting is a nightmare\\
            This is a poem\\-
        \end{poem}
        \textbf{Some text}
        \switchcolumn
        \section{Without the environment poem}
        Poem poem, please behave

        So my peace of mind you save

        Type-setting is a nightmare

        This is a poem

        \textbf{Some text}
    \end{paracol}

    \rule{\linewidth}{0.4pt}
    Modified

    \begin{paracol}{2}
        \section{With the environment poem}
        \poemtopskip=0pt%<---- modif 1em by default
        \poembotskip=0pt%<---- modif 1em by default
        %\setlength{\poemindent}{1in}%<---- for the indent 0pt by default
        \begin{poem}
            Poem poem, please behave\\
            So my peace of mind you save\\
            Type-setting is a nightmare\\
            This is a poem\\-
        \end{poem}
        \textbf{Some text}
        \switchcolumn
        \section{Without the environment poem}
        Poem poem, please behave

        So my peace of mind you save

        Type-setting is a nightmare

        This is a poem

        \textbf{Some text}
    \end{paracol}
    \end{document}